Who Has Done a Billion Dollars-Worth of Work?
Sheryl Sandberg, the COO of Facebook, recently became one of the world’s youngest female billionaires. The Bloomberg article about this featured a curious quote from David Kirkpatrick, author of The Facebook Effect.
“Did she do a billion dollars-worth of work? I don’t know. She had the good fortune to land in the right place where her talents could really be applauded.” (link)
Critics rightly took issue with the gender-bias inherent in this remark. You’d be hard-pressed to find a high-profile business publication questioning whether a rich man really earned his wealth, I suspect.
But beyond this particular offense, the implication that anyone has done “a billion dollars-worth of work” is rather absurd. That this absurdity isn’t recognized speaks to both a general problem of numeracy and to a specific problem of contextualizing large numbers.
What would a billion-dollars worth of work look like? In some ways it’s an ill-defined question, but we can explore some simple cases to get a sense of the answer.
Consider someone working for the current federal minimum wage of $7.25 an hour. A convenient rule-of-thumb approximation is that one’s hourly wage, doubled, is one’s yearly salary in thousands of dollars. (This assumes someone works 40 hours per week for 50 weeks per year, and so, a total of 2,000 hours per year.)
A full-time minimum wage worker therefore earns about $15,000 per year. At that rate, 7 years of work would be worth around $100,000, and so 70 years of work would be worth around $1 million. Since one billion is equal to 1,000 million, we see that $1 billion is equivalent to around 70,000 years of minimum wage-work.
Would any billionaire claim to have worked an equivalent of 70,000 years at minimum-wage? I doubt it. Not publicly, at least.
Some other benchmarks may help establish further context. For example, the average teacher salary in New York state is around $45,000 per year. Roughly speaking, that’s $100,000 every two years, and so $1 million every 20 years. Thus, $1 billion dollars is worth around 20,000 years of teacher-work.
What about highly-paid professionals? Surgeons typically earn around $250,000 per year. A quick calculation shows that a billion dollars is worth about 4,000 years of surgeon-work.
While the article suggests otherwise, to me, the answer to the question “Has anyone done a billion dolllars-worth of work?” is pretty clearly “No”.
An interesting follow-up question might be, “Has anyone created a billion dollars worth of value?”
2 Comments
Anonymous · January 30, 2014 at 9:34 pm
I think the real issue with this comparison is what Sandberg’s value in salary versus stock option.
According to the article, Sandberg’s “fortune” is the stake of her company, which approximates to 750 million, which is essentially a stock option. A quick search for Sandberg’s annual salary shows that she earns $328K a year, with a bonus of $227, which sort of determines the value of her work.
Having a stock option is the benefit of working for a company- not only is she valued for the work that she performs, but she earns an additional amount dependent on the well-being on the company. Which, of course, doesn’t apply to a teacher or a surgeon.
A teacher’s salary is based on multiple factors, mostly with the numbers of years of experience and the number of credits accumulated (the degree level obtained). In the case of a teacher, whose position is contracted to a union, we can’t argue anything about bonuses or stock options, mainly because teachers do not get either. A teacher will not earn more if the overall system of education is improving (although they should, considering their impact makes a difference).
For the surgeon, they also do not receive stock options, but their field is pretty lucrative. They will always be paid for their services- as the health insurance system will always benefit the doctor’s pocket but not always the patient’s.
And for your last question regarding “Has anyone created a billion dollars of value?”, I would most certainly agree that people have- in multiple forms. Of course, movie blockbusters can produce significant figures, as well as the construction of an impressive building or hotel. Whether ONE person could do such a task depends on the idea of “building value”.
A teacher can teach one hundred students a year- and essentially impact their lives and help build their value. Arguably, a teacher is the one who builds “a billion dollars of value” because a student’s education is invaluable and incalculably worthy.
Anonymous · January 31, 2014 at 10:44 pm
A correction to my first comment:
A bonus of 227K**